Crossing Genre Lines
Posted by Michelle under deep thoughts | Permalink | | Leave A Comment | 5 Comments
It’s funny where a random conversation can take you. I’d intended today to write a blog about Virginia’s Woolf’s famous piece about a room of one’s own and how things have changed (or not) in modern times, but instead I found myself woolgathering about the subject of genre after a random hallway conversation with a work acquaintance.
It all started with the subject of pen names and how many authors have them. She remarked that she had been amazed to find out that some authors have two or three pen names, and write different types of books under each name – like Snuggie Lovelace for romances, Jimmy Lasersight for science fiction, and L. P. Mystereo for mysteries. My coworker thought that the writers should be proud of their versatility and have a single name that stretched across the genres. But it’s not really a lack of pride that keeps writers from using the same name no matter what they write; there are other forces at play here.
I rolled out the usual explanations to her. Readers like to know what to expect when they pick up a new novel by a certain writer. Booksellers like to know where to shelve things. The marketing departments of publishing houses like to know where to spend their advertising dollars. It would be awfully silly to buy advertising space for the latest fantasy blockbuster in a magazine aimed at mystery enthusiasts. Having clear genre boundaries and everyone settled down into neat little boxes seems to make everything run a little smoother in the publishing industry. But smoother doesn’t necessarily make for great books….
In fact, the really great books seem to be the ones that break past these boundaries and defy the neat, orderly boxes of categorization. One of my favorite books, “The Time Traveler’s Wife” by Audrey Niffenegger, does this. It’s a romance. It’s science fiction. It’s a carefully crafted literary character study. It is a wonderful book that makes me laugh and cry every time I read it. I think publishers should publish more books like this in spite of the shelving and categorization confusion it might cause.
Thank goodness the Powers That Be in New York seem to be catching on. Cross-genre seems to be latest buzz word on literati circles – Romantic Mysteries, Urban Fantasy, Science Fiction Thrillers, the list goes on and on. So perhaps one day my coworker’s vision will come true and writers will only need one name, no matter how many different kinds of books they write.